The good : a very sturdy large diameter red dot finder. Red dot position can be easily and precisely adjusted
Plastic caps on each side open/close the tube, can also be used as a solar finder when closed (does work)

The included "Baader Universal Quick Release Finder Base" is very good, does fit several scope, (and locks reliably with 2 screws).

The average : a bit heavy (for the scope, and the wallet).
I find the red dot intensity at minimum level too bright for astronomy but ok for daytime use (I suppose this will get better with the battery wearing out)

Field test : I mounted my telrad and the baader sky surfer V side by side and tried star hoping. At the end of the day (night?), I find the telrad easier, but this could be because I am more used to it.
My personal conclusion is that : a guider scope + a red dot could be superior combination to a telrad, but that a telrad is more helpful than a guide scope or red dot alone (even the best red dot there is).


Bottom line : unlike the provided "Baader universal mounting plate" , this red dot will not stay on my main scope (C8).
However, I will keep it for day time use on my small C5 (for birdwatching), because it will not break (in my backpack, in the field, or anywhere else).

I was very impressed by the quality of this product. It was slightly larger than I expected but fitted all my requirements for a joint night and solar finder

Quality production in real metal and not wobbly plastic. SUPERB engineering and attention to detail.
Sits at a perfect height to use as it should be, with both eyes open. Very fine red dot which locates without hiding the target star. Quick and accurate to use......love it.
Expensive......well not cheap but when you consider that a Telrad may require a height platform addition, a dew shield (included on Surfer V) and extra bases to use on alternative telescopes its not much more expensive and it looks very well atop of your scope.
It also can be used for daytime solar work ( given the correct solar filters on your scope).
The only red dot finder I will ever need.

I liked my old Telrad but it did dew up from time to time. So far this one has not done so.
I use it with the lowest dot brightness setting so I can still easily see the stars I am lining up on. The battery has not run out even though I have twice accidentally left it on for days.

Clear, adjustable brightness and dot position using covered dials (20p slots in easily to adjust). It's supplied with hoods that prevent dew.
It doesn't magnify, just simply place the dot on the sky.
Only thing I would have liked is a 90degree prism for high elevation targets.

Just added a Baader Sky Surfer 5 to my CPC800 and WHAT AN IMPROVEMENT!!!

1. The sky surfer 5 oozes quality. Well made, all metal, dew covers. you adjust the dot position via a screw driver and every adjustment makes a lovely solid click sound that just gives you confidence that it aint going to slip out of alignment
2. Using the sky surfer reduces time to navigate by 95% compared to trying to use the supplied finder scope (and you also do not strain/break your neck in the process)

fyi, if youre interested there is an adaptor included that allowed attachment to the CPC800 without the need to buy any extra bits.

Overall I am well impressed.

Well after a couple of months using the standard finder on my 200p I simply could not star hop with the finder image reversed.
I started looking at red dot finders and was recommended to look at the sky surfer V.
It does cost more than the others but what a fantastic product. It fits straight onto the skywatcher base and has 2 adjustment screws that make tiny accurate adjustments and has 10 different brightness settings.
The build quality is 5 stars and star hopping is just so easy now.
It runs off a 2032 type battery which comes supplied and dew caps that are removable.
I'm so impressed with it I'm about to purchase a second one for my Dob.

Put simply this is faultless and well worth the outlay.

Danny.